The Reality of the “Polarization” Among MBA Holders
A rational perspective to end skepticism about MBAs “Even with an MBA, they’re useless.” “Many MBA holders are unpleasant to work with.”
Have you ever heard comments like these?
It’s true, such people exist. But letting them drag down the overall value of the MBA is an enormous waste.
This article is written for:
・Those considering an MBA but feeling uncertain because of outside opinions
・Those who became skeptical about MBAs after meeting difficult MBA holders
・Those who know MBA quality varies greatly and are unsure which school to choose
・Please read this for your own success!**
And note: this doesn’t apply only to MBAs. The same is true for other graduate programs and for career paths in general—so try to reinterpret this in light of your own goals.
The Reality of the “Polarization” Among MBA Holders
・At Alpha, we state clearly: “You should pursue an MBA (in fact, without it there is no real future),” and there are solid reasons behind this.
・If you want to thrive globally, an MBA functions almost like a license. Just as a bachelor’s degree is required to enter a major consulting firm, an MBA is the baseline credential for those aiming to lead in global business.
・However, MBA holders tend to fall into two very different categories:
Type A: Those who truly excel
・View the MBA purely as a tool for advancing their careers
・Commit themselves to missions that create meaningful positive impact in the world
・Do not spend their time endlessly recounting “my MBA experience”
・Make calm, rational decisions
Type B: Those considered problematic
・Pursued the MBA mainly to cure academic insecurity or for status
・Keep bragging: “I got my MBA”
・Chose elite schools for superficial, trend-driven reasons
・Did not attend a truly competitive MBA program or failed to build a strong career afterward
The real problem is that society lumps both groups together as simply “MBA holders.”
If someone happens to meet a Type B, they may conclude, “MBAs aren’t worth much.”
If they meet a Type A, they may think, “This is the kind of leader an MBA produces.”
Consider the example of a top university.
It’s easier to understand if we compare.
I once studied at a top university. From what I saw, most people were fine. But with so many students, inevitably, some later got into serious trouble.
Yet no one would say, “Graduates of that university are prone to crime,” right?
The same logic applies to MBAs. The key is to view it with a calm, rational lens: “Do I need this for my career?” Without bias, the decision becomes clearer.
To add context: nearly everyone initially starts out with insecurities or ambitions to chase a more prestigious career. That’s fine. But through the MBA application process, those vague motivations evolve into something deeper—a genuine life mission. That mission then gets articulated in essays with logical coherence. When this happens, even applicants with unconventional backgrounds can gain admission to top U.S. schools.
It’s a tough process—not so much physically demanding as it is about how honestly you can confront yourself. At Alpha, we see about one or two applicants each year (roughly 0.3%) who cannot endure this process. They fall into what we call “throwaway syndrome,” writing careless essays just to get it over with. Of course, that’s their personal choice—but honestly, it’s such a waste.
The Value of an MBA in the AI Era
It is true that in today’s AI-driven era, simply holding an MBA is no longer enough. What is required includes:
・A solid understanding of technology
・Human qualities that make others prefer working with you over AI
・Dual degrees in areas such as data science
In fact, those who have earned dual degrees in MBA and data science are in extremely high demand during job searches.
・On the other hand, the employment rate for Harvard Business School graduates has declined, with 25% of graduates reportedly without confirmed job offers. This is likely influenced by the perception that HBS remains heavily case-study based and weaker in technology.
The Importance of School Selection
・At Alpha, we introduce a wide range of MBA programs, but as many of you may have noticed, there are schools we do not actively recommend. (We know you watch our videos very closely…!)
・This judgment is based on over 20 years of experience by our founder, who has observed countless graduates, combined with my own experience at Columbia, insights from global finance recruiters, and—most importantly—actual hiring outcomes (the one thing that cannot be faked!).
・As a rule of thumb, top investment banks and global financial firms are the most selective, given their very limited intake. In contrast, consulting—while a traditional MBA path—hires from almost every school, though regional factors still apply. (That said, consulting is also entering a more difficult phase in the AI era.)
・For Japanese candidates in particular, environments where people drag each other down or are prone to status games are best avoided. These cultural issues can negatively affect job hunting outcomes as well.
Don’t Be Misled by Personal Stories
・This is the season when newly admitted students publish their personal accounts, but the critical question is: “Is this a success story?”
・Individual abilities—such as language skills, academic background, and intellectual capacity—differ dramatically. While reading these accounts can boost motivation, relying on unsuccessful examples is risky.
・If your goal is to enter a top university, you wouldn’t base your preparation on the experiences of someone who failed to get in, right? The same logic applies here.
Real Success Stories
Case 1: Clarifying a Long-Term Career Goal
“I believe I was finally able to define my long-term career goal, which had been vague for years, and now I have no doubts. Previously, when I read testimonials from others who had joined Alpha’s career strategy advisory, I thought their descriptions were somewhat exaggerated. But now, I feel the same excitement—I can’t wait to move forward toward my goal.
I have watched nearly all of Alpha’s videos, so I was aware of the potential career paths such as joining BlackRock (a leading global asset management firm). However, during my kickoff meeting, TJ thoroughly examined the decision-making behind my past career choices and what I aspire to accomplish. He understood me deeply and offered strategic insights from a broader perspective, helping me answer the fundamental question: ‘Why pursue a career in global asset management?’
I realized that, despite consuming a lot of Alpha’s content, my decision to aim for private equity had been shallow. I now fully appreciate the importance of receiving advice from true professionals to achieve an ideal career. Going forward, I would like continued support in developing concrete strategies (including overseas MBA plans) to achieve my long-term goals. Today feels like a turning point in my life. I am truly grateful.”
Case 2: Admitted to a Master’s in Financial Engineering
“The decisive turning point for me in reassessing my career path and deciding to apply to a financial engineering program came just before my final interview for a second-year recruitment and a trading company position. During the kickoff meeting, I was asked: ‘What do you truly want to accomplish at the core of your being?’ and was told, ‘Moving from one domestic firm to another is not real career advancement.’ These words struck deeply and prompted me to fundamentally rethink my values and direction.
With Alpha’s precise support, I refined my application strategy and submitted my résumé to the admissions office. Almost immediately, I received strong encouragement to apply. The speed and strength of that response made me realize just how critical résumé content really is. From essay writing to interview preparation, I received continuous, detailed guidance, which ultimately led to my admission.
I sincerely thank everyone at Alpha Advisors for always challenging me to reflect on the essence of my goals and for walking this journey alongside me with genuine dedication.”
Case 3: Mid-Career Success Through EMBA and Career Transition
“I just received the news from the Chicago EMBA admissions office: ‘Accepted’!
I owe this achievement to the dedicated guidance and support from TJ and Emi throughout the process. I am truly delighted to have reached this milestone—thank you so much!
Through class visits, I found the Chicago EMBA to be a highly attractive program and I am essentially planning to enroll. Since I still have some time before the decision deadline, I will be preparing carefully while considering practical matters such as financing and negotiating company sponsorship. I look forward to continuing to receive your guidance—not only for my preparation toward the EMBA but also for my career transition strategy that aligns with my long-term goals.”
“I am currently enrolled in an EMBA program in the U.S., and the advice I received from Alpha was invaluable in understanding both the importance of obtaining an MBA at the executive level and which companies and positions to target. Based on that, I was able to reassess my career vision and build a clear roadmap for the medium to long term.
As a result, I successfully secured my next career opportunity with a significant salary increase and a clear five- to ten-year outlook. Some of the offers came via recruiters, but I often found their advice to be biased by their own business interests and not particularly helpful. In contrast, Alpha Advisors provided the exact opposite: candid, long-term, and candidate-focused guidance. I am deeply grateful for the perspective and support that put my career development first.”
Rational Decision-Making
If you want to succeed, you must not be swayed by casual opinions around you—acting with rational judgment is essential.
It is true that MBAs are expensive, and for many, financial barriers or lack of English proficiency feel like obstacles. But dismissing MBAs altogether as “useless” because of these reasons is far too simplistic. What truly matters is to clarify your career goals and assess calmly whether an MBA is necessary to achieve them.
At Alpha, We Help You Maximize Your Potential. Three Actions You Can Take Right Now!
・Schedule a free consultation about MBA or career planning
We will help you clarify your current situation and determine whether pursuing an MBA is truly the right move for you.
・Make 2025 Your MBA Year
If you start your application strategy now for 2025 entry, you still have plenty of time to succeed.
・Get expert support in selecting the right school
With over 20 years of experience and networks, we will recommend the schools best suited to your goals.
Why Not Start With a Free Consultation?
Let us help you define your career goals, determine whether an MBA is really necessary, and identify the schools that best fit your path. (Detailed school selection and career planning are part of our paid personalized coaching. It is professional guidance that clients consistently find transformative.)
Now is the time to shut out the noise around you and think seriously about your future.
We truly look forward to speaking with you!
Editor’s Note
It has been about five years since I joined Alpha. Before that, I was on the other side—as a student preparing for MBA and graduate school applications in education.
At that time, my entire focus was on getting admitted to my target schools, succeeding in job hunting after studying abroad, and preparing to launch my own business. I interned at a global strategy consulting firm and even received a full-time offer, but I realized consulting was not the path I wanted. Since then, I have met and spoken directly with well over 8,000 people through Alpha.
In the early days, I would spend around 30 minutes with each individual, listening carefully to their current situation before introducing Alpha’s paid MBA and career coaching programs. Over the years, this constant dialogue has given me unparalleled insight into the realities of MBA and graduate school admissions, as well as the truth about career transitions. I can confidently say this is one of the things I am most proud of. Of course, there are many outstanding professionals in other fields, but when it comes to this area, I believe Alpha Advisors and I are without a doubt the leading experts in Japan.
Today, many of our students are preparing with hope and determination for MBA and graduate school admissions. Increasingly, I also have the chance to speak with leaders at private equity funds, multinational corporations, and global recruiters. Through those conversations, combined with what I have witnessed firsthand at Alpha, I have gained a clear view of the real truths behind career success. That is what I want to share openly here.
Right now is the season when those who have been admitted to MBA programs share their success stories—announcing which schools they got into or when they will begin their studies abroad. At the same time, others who aim to apply this year are actively gathering information. In this age where information is overflowing, I know many of you are putting in the effort with genuine determination to succeed. I want all of you not just to succeed, but to achieve extraordinary success.
And that success should not just be for yourself. My wish is that you become global business leaders who, in your chosen fields, enable many others to succeed and find happiness, ultimately making the world better. That is the spirit in which I write this message.
At Alpha, we too are working to expand more globally and are leveraging AI to help more people around the world thrive. Let’s take on these challenges together.
Favorite
The Reality of the “Polarization” Among MBA Holders
A rational perspective to end skepticism about MBAs
“Even with an MBA, they’re useless.”
“Many MBA holders are unpleasant to work with.”
Have you ever heard comments like these?
It’s true, such people exist. But letting them drag down the overall value of the MBA is an enormous waste.
This article is written for:
・Those considering an MBA but feeling uncertain because of outside opinions
・Those who became skeptical about MBAs after meeting difficult MBA holders
・Those who know MBA quality varies greatly and are unsure which school to choose
・Please read this for your own success!**
And note: this doesn’t apply only to MBAs. The same is true for other graduate programs and for career paths in general—so try to reinterpret this in light of your own goals.
The Reality of the “Polarization” Among MBA Holders
・At Alpha, we state clearly: “You should pursue an MBA (in fact, without it there is no real future),” and there are solid reasons behind this.
・If you want to thrive globally, an MBA functions almost like a license. Just as a bachelor’s degree is required to enter a major consulting firm, an MBA is the baseline credential for those aiming to lead in global business.
・However, MBA holders tend to fall into two very different categories:
Type A: Those who truly excel
・View the MBA purely as a tool for advancing their careers
・Commit themselves to missions that create meaningful positive impact in the world
・Do not spend their time endlessly recounting “my MBA experience”
・Make calm, rational decisions
Type B: Those considered problematic
・Pursued the MBA mainly to cure academic insecurity or for status
・Keep bragging: “I got my MBA”
・Chose elite schools for superficial, trend-driven reasons
・Did not attend a truly competitive MBA program or failed to build a strong career afterward
The real problem is that society lumps both groups together as simply “MBA holders.”
If someone happens to meet a Type B, they may conclude, “MBAs aren’t worth much.”
If they meet a Type A, they may think, “This is the kind of leader an MBA produces.”
Consider the example of a top university.
It’s easier to understand if we compare.
I once studied at a top university. From what I saw, most people were fine. But with so many students, inevitably, some later got into serious trouble.
Yet no one would say, “Graduates of that university are prone to crime,” right?
The same logic applies to MBAs. The key is to view it with a calm, rational lens: “Do I need this for my career?” Without bias, the decision becomes clearer.
To add context: nearly everyone initially starts out with insecurities or ambitions to chase a more prestigious career. That’s fine. But through the MBA application process, those vague motivations evolve into something deeper—a genuine life mission. That mission then gets articulated in essays with logical coherence. When this happens, even applicants with unconventional backgrounds can gain admission to top U.S. schools.
It’s a tough process—not so much physically demanding as it is about how honestly you can confront yourself. At Alpha, we see about one or two applicants each year (roughly 0.3%) who cannot endure this process. They fall into what we call “throwaway syndrome,” writing careless essays just to get it over with. Of course, that’s their personal choice—but honestly, it’s such a waste.
The Value of an MBA in the AI Era
It is true that in today’s AI-driven era, simply holding an MBA is no longer enough. What is required includes:
・A solid understanding of technology
・Human qualities that make others prefer working with you over AI
・Dual degrees in areas such as data science
In fact, those who have earned dual degrees in MBA and data science are in extremely high demand during job searches.
・On the other hand, the employment rate for Harvard Business School graduates has declined, with 25% of graduates reportedly without confirmed job offers. This is likely influenced by the perception that HBS remains heavily case-study based and weaker in technology.
The Importance of School Selection
・At Alpha, we introduce a wide range of MBA programs, but as many of you may have noticed, there are schools we do not actively recommend. (We know you watch our videos very closely…!)
・This judgment is based on over 20 years of experience by our founder, who has observed countless graduates, combined with my own experience at Columbia, insights from global finance recruiters, and—most importantly—actual hiring outcomes (the one thing that cannot be faked!).
・As a rule of thumb, top investment banks and global financial firms are the most selective, given their very limited intake. In contrast, consulting—while a traditional MBA path—hires from almost every school, though regional factors still apply. (That said, consulting is also entering a more difficult phase in the AI era.)
・For Japanese candidates in particular, environments where people drag each other down or are prone to status games are best avoided. These cultural issues can negatively affect job hunting outcomes as well.
Don’t Be Misled by Personal Stories
・This is the season when newly admitted students publish their personal accounts, but the critical question is: “Is this a success story?”
・Individual abilities—such as language skills, academic background, and intellectual capacity—differ dramatically. While reading these accounts can boost motivation, relying on unsuccessful examples is risky.
・If your goal is to enter a top university, you wouldn’t base your preparation on the experiences of someone who failed to get in, right? The same logic applies here.
Real Success Stories
Case 1: Clarifying a Long-Term Career Goal
“I believe I was finally able to define my long-term career goal, which had been vague for years, and now I have no doubts. Previously, when I read testimonials from others who had joined Alpha’s career strategy advisory, I thought their descriptions were somewhat exaggerated. But now, I feel the same excitement—I can’t wait to move forward toward my goal.
I have watched nearly all of Alpha’s videos, so I was aware of the potential career paths such as joining BlackRock (a leading global asset management firm). However, during my kickoff meeting, TJ thoroughly examined the decision-making behind my past career choices and what I aspire to accomplish. He understood me deeply and offered strategic insights from a broader perspective, helping me answer the fundamental question: ‘Why pursue a career in global asset management?’
I realized that, despite consuming a lot of Alpha’s content, my decision to aim for private equity had been shallow. I now fully appreciate the importance of receiving advice from true professionals to achieve an ideal career. Going forward, I would like continued support in developing concrete strategies (including overseas MBA plans) to achieve my long-term goals. Today feels like a turning point in my life. I am truly grateful.”
Case 2: Admitted to a Master’s in Financial Engineering
“The decisive turning point for me in reassessing my career path and deciding to apply to a financial engineering program came just before my final interview for a second-year recruitment and a trading company position. During the kickoff meeting, I was asked: ‘What do you truly want to accomplish at the core of your being?’ and was told, ‘Moving from one domestic firm to another is not real career advancement.’ These words struck deeply and prompted me to fundamentally rethink my values and direction.
With Alpha’s precise support, I refined my application strategy and submitted my résumé to the admissions office. Almost immediately, I received strong encouragement to apply. The speed and strength of that response made me realize just how critical résumé content really is. From essay writing to interview preparation, I received continuous, detailed guidance, which ultimately led to my admission.
I sincerely thank everyone at Alpha Advisors for always challenging me to reflect on the essence of my goals and for walking this journey alongside me with genuine dedication.”
Case 3: Mid-Career Success Through EMBA and Career Transition
“I just received the news from the Chicago EMBA admissions office: ‘Accepted’!
I owe this achievement to the dedicated guidance and support from TJ and Emi throughout the process. I am truly delighted to have reached this milestone—thank you so much!
Through class visits, I found the Chicago EMBA to be a highly attractive program and I am essentially planning to enroll. Since I still have some time before the decision deadline, I will be preparing carefully while considering practical matters such as financing and negotiating company sponsorship. I look forward to continuing to receive your guidance—not only for my preparation toward the EMBA but also for my career transition strategy that aligns with my long-term goals.”
“I am currently enrolled in an EMBA program in the U.S., and the advice I received from Alpha was invaluable in understanding both the importance of obtaining an MBA at the executive level and which companies and positions to target. Based on that, I was able to reassess my career vision and build a clear roadmap for the medium to long term.
As a result, I successfully secured my next career opportunity with a significant salary increase and a clear five- to ten-year outlook. Some of the offers came via recruiters, but I often found their advice to be biased by their own business interests and not particularly helpful. In contrast, Alpha Advisors provided the exact opposite: candid, long-term, and candidate-focused guidance. I am deeply grateful for the perspective and support that put my career development first.”
Rational Decision-Making
If you want to succeed, you must not be swayed by casual opinions around you—acting with rational judgment is essential.
It is true that MBAs are expensive, and for many, financial barriers or lack of English proficiency feel like obstacles. But dismissing MBAs altogether as “useless” because of these reasons is far too simplistic.
What truly matters is to clarify your career goals and assess calmly whether an MBA is necessary to achieve them.
At Alpha, We Help You Maximize Your Potential. Three Actions You Can Take Right Now!
・Schedule a free consultation about MBA or career planning
We will help you clarify your current situation and determine whether pursuing an MBA is truly the right move for you.
・Make 2025 Your MBA Year
If you start your application strategy now for 2025 entry, you still have plenty of time to succeed.
・Get expert support in selecting the right school
With over 20 years of experience and networks, we will recommend the schools best suited to your goals.
Why Not Start With a Free Consultation?
Let us help you define your career goals, determine whether an MBA is really necessary, and identify the schools that best fit your path. (Detailed school selection and career planning are part of our paid personalized coaching. It is professional guidance that clients consistently find transformative.)
Free Consultation Here! ＞ Free Consultation
Now is the time to shut out the noise around you and think seriously about your future.
We truly look forward to speaking with you!
Editor’s Note
It has been about five years since I joined Alpha. Before that, I was on the other side—as a student preparing for MBA and graduate school applications in education.
At that time, my entire focus was on getting admitted to my target schools, succeeding in job hunting after studying abroad, and preparing to launch my own business. I interned at a global strategy consulting firm and even received a full-time offer, but I realized consulting was not the path I wanted. Since then, I have met and spoken directly with well over 8,000 people through Alpha.
In the early days, I would spend around 30 minutes with each individual, listening carefully to their current situation before introducing Alpha’s paid MBA and career coaching programs. Over the years, this constant dialogue has given me unparalleled insight into the realities of MBA and graduate school admissions, as well as the truth about career transitions. I can confidently say this is one of the things I am most proud of. Of course, there are many outstanding professionals in other fields, but when it comes to this area, I believe Alpha Advisors and I are without a doubt the leading experts in Japan.
Today, many of our students are preparing with hope and determination for MBA and graduate school admissions. Increasingly, I also have the chance to speak with leaders at private equity funds, multinational corporations, and global recruiters. Through those conversations, combined with what I have witnessed firsthand at Alpha, I have gained a clear view of the real truths behind career success. That is what I want to share openly here.
Right now is the season when those who have been admitted to MBA programs share their success stories—announcing which schools they got into or when they will begin their studies abroad. At the same time, others who aim to apply this year are actively gathering information. In this age where information is overflowing, I know many of you are putting in the effort with genuine determination to succeed. I want all of you not just to succeed, but to achieve extraordinary success.
And that success should not just be for yourself. My wish is that you become global business leaders who, in your chosen fields, enable many others to succeed and find happiness, ultimately making the world better. That is the spirit in which I write this message.
At Alpha, we too are working to expand more globally and are leveraging AI to help more people around the world thrive. Let’s take on these challenges together.